By JOHN BOHNENKAMP
Mia Nicastro didn’t think she would be wearing a Western Illinois uniform this season.
Her four years of eligibility were up when the Leathernecks lost to North Carolina in the first round of the NCAA Tournament last March. Nicastro’s plan was to play somewhere professionally this season, and she had signed a contract to play in Greece.
Then along came a court ruling that granted Nicastro and more than 90 other athletes a chance at a fifth season.
And now Nicastro, the Ohio Valley Conference’s player of the year last season and one of the nation’s top mid-major players, is a Leatherneck again.
“Obviously, it’s an incredibly unique experience, one that I didn’t think I would have,” Nicastro said after last Wednesday’s 74-41 win over Cornell College at Western Hall. “I mean, I fully expected to be in Greece right now, kind of living a completely different life. So I’m just kind of taking every day as an opportunity.”
The lawsuit Nicastro was involved in was one of many filed around the nation against the NCAA after the organization passed its new “5 for 5” rule that granted athletes, beginning with those from the 2023 recruiting class, five years of eligibility. The athletes who sued the NCAA were members of the 2022 class, who sought to be included in the new rule.
An Indiana judge granted a preliminary injunction that allowed the athletes a fifth year of eligibility, and the Indiana Court of Appeals denied the NCAA’s motion to pause or stay the injunction and also denied a motion to expedite the appeal. Under the calendar set by the court, any ruling by the court won’t come until early next year.
“I would say right now I feel pretty confident (about playing the entire season),” Nicastro said. “We’re just kind of playing it out, but I would say that I’m pretty confident I’m in it for the long haul.”
Nicastro, who also was the OVC’s Female Athlete of the Year last season, started her career at Saint Louis, but transferred to Western Illinois for her final two seasons. She averaged 15.3 points in the 2024-25 season, then was fourth in NCAA Division I in scoring last season at 24.1 points.
But Nicastro said coming back to the Leathernecks was an adjustment, because in a lot of ways this was a different team than what she played on last season. Three players who were in the starting lineup with her for that NCAA Tournament game — Mallory Shetley, Addi Brownfield and Allie Meadows — are no longer with the team, since they were out of eligibility. Raegan McCowan, second on the team in scoring last season before an elbow injury sidelined her for the second half of the season, transferred to Houston.
“I really have to give props to my teammates and my coaches,” Nicastro said. “I mean, they welcomed me back just really, really seamlessly. And the girls have been great. Obviously, it’s a different team. We lost a lot of the girls that I was close with last year. But again, it’s back to the opportunity thing. Here’s an opportunity to get closer with some new people, some great girls, and rekindle my relationships with the coaches that I’m already really close with. And there’s kind of an opportunity to lead and help some of the younger girls find their footing.”
“I think she’s embracing the role of helping the younger kids come along,” Western Illinois coach JD Gravina said. “It’s difficult. Those kids she played with were so experienced. I think she’s now starting to embrace that leadership with the younger players and the new players. You have to come together as a team first before you can have that impact. I think when she first came in, she didn’t have the relationships with some of the younger and new players that she had last year. I think she’s been building those.”
Gravina said he understands what Nicastro has faced.
“Everything about it has been so new and unique for me as a coach, and for her as a player and a teammate,” Gravina said. “I think it’s been fun, but it’s been a challenge. When we thought about her coming back, we thought she’s so experienced, so ‘Mia Nicastro.’ I didn’t even think there would be challenges, honestly.
“I think there were a lot of mental aspects to it. ‘Are you eligible? Are you not? Are you being a leader?’ And then I think, for the players, there was this celebrity coming back. So it was very different from what I expected just how far it was for me as a coach to manage all of that.”
Nicastro was able to get out of her pro contract in Greece, and came back to Western Illinois to get an MBA, but while she waited on the ruling on the lawsuit, she could do some participation in workouts with the Leathernecks as a former player.
“I think it was a little tough, especially when I first came back,” she said. “I mean, I wasn’t fully eligible. I really came back on the hope that this was all going to work out, and I kind of just kind of had a feeling that this is what I should do. I prayed a lot about it, and I decided that even though it wasn’t 100%, I should come back. So I think it was a little tough at the beginning. It’s hard when you expect that you’re going to be doing one thing, and then all of a sudden in a day it completely switches and you’re doing another. And I think it just kind of felt … I personally felt like I wasn’t supposed to be here, like something was kind of wrong.”
“I think there were times when she was uncomfortable, and I did not see that coming,” Gravina said. “But I think it’s probably been good for her, and for us. I think she’s worked through that, and it’s going to make her better in the long run and our team better in the long run.”
Nicastro is averaging 17 points per game in the first four games of the season.
“She worked hard in the offseason because she was going to be a pro basketball player,” Gravina said. “But I think it was a different mentality of ‘I have to get stronger, I have to get more physical. And then when you get back to the college level, which plays faster, and getting back into game shape, that was a little bit of a challenge. Plus she was battling some nagging injuries, and there was the whole thing of getting comfortable again.
“I don’t think she felt like a full member of the team until games started, which is crazy to think about, but I get it. I think it took that long for her to feel that she’s not different, that she was the same as she used to be. I think we’re at that point now, that this is more natural.”
“It’s great having her back,” said forward Maria Messling, who would have played Nicastro’s spot at the ‘5’ this season but has moved to the ‘4’.”Obviously she’s a really elite scorer, so that helps our team. It helps our offense. So, yeah, it’s good to have her here.”
It’s a final chance for Nicastro to play college basketball, and it’s one she is savoring.
“I think it’s just kind of trying to grow in the mindset that every day that I have here is an opportunity,” she said. “I got the opportunity to come back here. This is what I fought for. This is what I wanted since I found out it was a possibility in August. And so, while there has been a little bit of an adjustment and some roadblocks along the way as expected, I’m just really grateful to be be around people that I love, people that love me, people that support me, and people that for two years before this helped me grow immensely as a player and a person.”
Photo: Western Illinois’ Mia Nicastro (right) is back after being granted a fifth year of eligibility in an Indiana court ruling. (Photo by John Gaines)
