By JOHN BOHNENKAMP
DES MOINES — Welcome to Iowa’s Stockdale Paradox.
The Hawkeyes’ 70-69 loss to Creighton on Sunday at the Casey’s Center was their second defeat in five days, and dropped them to 2-2 on the season.
They’re a team without a “gravity,” as coach Ben McCollum described it before the season. McCollum is still searching for his star or stars, a go-to player or players in the combination that he wants out on the court in close games.
McCollum, though, thinks his team is going to get to that point where it can win the games like the one lost on Sunday, and the one lost in overtime to Virginia Tech last Tuesday.
And that is where Iowa’s Stockdale Paradox lies.
The concept comes from author Jim Collins in the book Good to Great, and it’s what McCollum quoted in his post-game press conference.
“I think we’re closer than we think,” he said. “I really do. I think you’re going to see it. I think you’re going to see it slowly flip. I don’t know when, but it’s like the old Stockdale Paradox. You know, it’s just, like, eventually things are going to flip for you if you just keep doing the right things and kind of face what the brutal facts are today.”
The brutal facts confronting the Hawkeyes at this point of a season that is only two weeks old is that the players McCollum thinks could be part of his closing combinations of games aren’t producing, and those on the court are making mistakes that, while correctable, are still damaging the progress.
These two defeats are an education, and McCollum is hoping his team is learning.
“It’s helped us a lot,” he said. “ I do think that you know it’s like one of those process things that as you go, you learn a little more and a little more and a little more, and it’s like OK, yeah, I understand that we lost and we shouldn’t have lost.”
The Hawkeyes had 15 turnovers. They missed seven free throws, much better than the 16 that they missed on Tuesday, but they were still points left behind. Trevin Jirak had 22 points, but wasn’t on the court at the end after fouling out with 3:42 to play. And twice in the first half, in the span of less than a minute, Iowa defenders fouled Creighton shooters on 3-point attempts.
“Et cetera, et cetera,” McCollum said. “Man, we’re getting closer and closer. I do feel like that.”
“Dumb fouls,” Jirak said of his own performance. “Dumb mistakes.”
The final shot of the game came from McCollum’s son, Peyton, but he wasn’t the main option on the play. Kael Combs drove to the basket exactly as Ben McCollum wanted, because a.) McCollum knew he could get to the basket and b.) he likely could get a foul on a day when 46 of them were called.
Combs got deep into the lane, but passed the ball out to Peyton McCollum, who had one of Iowa’s three second-half 3-pointers. McCollum’s shot was short, and Creighton’s Katrelle Harmon grabbed the rebound and immediately threw the ball toward his own basket to take away the final second of the game.
“We wanted Kael downhill because they were in foul trouble, and I thought he got there,” Ben McCollum said. “I thought he got to a spot. I thought he was going to shoot it. I think out of the periphery, (Combs saw) Payton was wide open, so he kicked.
“We wanted to make sure that we put some pressure on the defense, and I thought he did a good job of getting where he needed to get. Just wasn’t able to get a shot. I kind of wanted him to shoot that because those are shorter rebounds and you could get that. Those longer rebounds are a little trickier. We wanted to make sure we got to the rim a little bit. But again, we got a good look. Just didn’t knock it down.”
The final five on the court for that last play were Combs, Peyton McCollum, Isaia Howard, Tate Sage and Cooper Koch. Combs is the lone fourth-year player among that group.
“Those guys are all young, young players,” Ben McCollum said.
Last year, those final seconds would have belonged to Bennett Stirtz, the “gravity” that McCollum has mentioned. Stirtz, though, is in the NBA now.
“I mean, Bennett was a first-round pick, so obviously you don’t have that on the court,” Jirak said. “But, you know, we still believe in what we’ve got and the group that we’ve got, and it just comes down to making plays at the end of the game.
“And I think we’re all capable of that.”
Sage seemed destined for a “gravity” role after the way he played at the end of last season as a freshman, but he is averaging seven points per game and missed all five of his shots in Sunday’s game.
That’s another flip McCollum is expecting.
“I’m hoping it flips because we need him to be really good,” he said. “I still think he’s one of our best players. I still think he’s one of our best players. I think there’s probably some undue pressure that he puts on himself to be a stud. And sometimes when you try to create a result, sometimes then your process isn’t what it needs to be. I think it’s a good growing pain that he’s going to have right now, and he’s going to overcome it. He’s going to be excellent for us, and probably as early as next game.”
McCollum is hoping for a similar flip from fourth-year forward Cam Manyawu, who came off the bench and played less than three minutes.
“I just need him to be Cam,” McCollum said. ”I need him to be Cam. I need him to be energetic. I need him to be physical. I need him to provide. I need him to do things. You know what he can do, and he hasn’t done that yet.”
McCollum came to Iowa last season, and that first-year process ended with a trip to the NCAA Tournament’s Elite Eight.
“The way they do things, you watch them on film, and it makes you question a little bit what you’re doing because they are so solid, so disciplined, and I’ve got a lot of respect for them,” Creighton coach Alan Huss said.
Jirak said the solution for the Hawkeyes is simple.
“Yeah, just go back to work, get better every day, and you know hopefully we turn these L’s into W’s,” he said. “But you know, we’ve just got to get better every day.”
Call what the Hawkeyes are facing now the McCollum Paradox.
“We’ve got to get better at this, and then just keep getting better at it,” he said, “and eventually good things will happen for you.”
Photo: Iowa guard Peyton McCollum gets into a defensive stance as he waits for Creighton guard Wes Enis to bring the ball up court. (Brian Ray/hawkeyesports.com)
